You’ve got a good business. Work is coming in, the team is growing, and somewhere along the way someone said, “We really need to sort out our marketing.”
So you start looking. And the first decision lands on your desk: do you hire an agency, or do you need a marketing manager?
Most business owners I meet in Perth have asked this question at least once. Most of them have also tried the wrong answer first. Here’s how to work out which one you actually need.
What an agency is built to do
A good agency is brilliant at execution. You tell them what you want (a new website, a Google Ads campaign, a month of social posts) and they produce it. They have specialists, systems and software, and they can turn work around quickly.
What an agency usually isn’t set up to do is decide what you should be doing in the first place. They take a brief. If the brief is wrong, you get a very well-made version of the wrong thing.
That’s not a criticism. It’s just how the model works. Agencies sell services, and their account managers juggle a lot of clients. They’re not sitting in your weekly meeting hearing that your biggest client is wobbling, or that you’ve just hired three estimators and need more work through the door.
What a marketing manager is built to do
A marketing manager’s job is to own the outcome, not the output.
They work out where your work comes from now and where it should come from next. They decide what’s worth spending on and what isn’t. They write the brief, choose the right supplier, check the work, and measure whether it did anything. And they keep it all moving when you’re busy running the business.
In a bigger company, that’s a full-time employee. For most businesses with 10 to 100 staff, a full-time hire is hard to justify, and harder to find. Good, experienced marketing managers are expensive, and a junior hire without direction tends to end up posting on Instagram and not much else.
Five signs you need a manager, not (just) an agency
1. You can’t write the brief. If you’re not sure what you want an agency to do, you need strategy before you need execution.
2. You’ve paid for marketing and can’t tell if it worked. Activity without measurement usually means nobody owns the result.
3. You’re the marketing department. If the MD or office manager is approving social posts at 9pm, the business has outgrown that setup.
4. You’ve got several suppliers and nobody joining the dots. Web developer, ads person, a photographer, someone doing LinkedIn. Each doing their bit, nobody steering.
5. Your marketing doesn’t sound like your business. Generic copy, stock photos, the same message as every competitor. That happens when the people writing it have never set foot on your site.
If two or more of those sound familiar, an agency on its own won’t fix it.
Signs an agency is the right call
To be fair, sometimes an agency is exactly what you need:
- You already have a clear strategy and someone internally who owns it.
- You need one specific project done well (a website rebuild, for example).
- You need specialist horsepower at scale, such as a large paid media budget across several platforms.
In those cases, a manager can still help you pick the right agency and keep them accountable, but you may not need one ongoing.
The middle option most businesses don’t know about
There’s a third model, and it’s the one I work in: a contract marketing manager.
You get an experienced marketing lead who works inside your business, part-time, without the cost of a full-time salary. They’re in your office or on site when it matters, they sit in the meetings where decisions get made, and they run the work in between, either doing it themselves or managing the right specialists.
For a business with budget and opportunity but no marketing team, it’s usually the fastest way to go from “we should really do something about marketing” to a plan that’s actually running.
A simple test
Ask yourself one question: if I hired an agency tomorrow, could I tell them exactly what to do and how to measure it?
If the answer is yes, call an agency.
If the answer is “not really”, you need someone to own your marketing first. That’s the conversation I have with business owners every week.
Not sure which one fits your business? Book a 30-minute discovery call. I’ll ask about your goals, your team and what you’ve tried, and give you a straight answer, even if that answer is “you don’t need me yet”.